- Hello from Syria!
- What I say to people who tell me I’m motivated by pride to question the Church
- Why I love First Things
- Catholics and Republicans on same-sex marriage and public reason
- Please don’t leave the Catholic Church!
- So, being 28…
- On Overthinking (and Susan Boyle)
- How Heresy Becomes Theology
- Why talking to certain Catholics is like talking to communists
- Changes to the Blog
- More Blog Entries
I do know this: There are a number of homosexual men either working as priests or in the seminary that take the promise of celibacy seriously and place their sexuality in a place behind their ministry or studies, this is what I like to think is asked of all men called to the priesthood. It was the method I used when I was studying as a seminarian to be successful in controlling the urges brought about by the different relationships with women that I was blessed with. I did not ignore my sexuality, I put it second or third or even further distant to the ministry of the Church. I still appreciated the sight of a beautiful woman and the friendship of many female companions but never made sex the focus of those things. I like to believe that we can allow our gay seminarians and priests the same latitude. I know many men that have mastered their sexuality and, while attracted to other men, don’t make it the focus of their relationships and dealings with those men. I think we need to reevaluate the way we appraoch admission to our seminaries. There must be a stronger evaluation and examination of every man to determine whether he is able to place his sexuality on the back burner and place their focus on the ministry of the Church and service to God. Finally, it wouldn’t hurt us to be a bit more open to criticism from the outside world. I know we are America and we do almost everything better than everybody else but, we can use a little help when it comes to ideas like humility and obedience.
Jeff


This is my problem with the whole excluding gays from the priesthood issue–there are those who will take their position and its demands seriously, and those who won’t, whether they are gay or straight. Sexual orientation really shouldn’t be an issue with a priest, since they are supposed to be celibate anyway. Especially since the Catholic church basically says there is no way for a gay relationship to be sanctified–why should a devout catholic man who knows he’s gay (but can also control himself) not be allowed to devote his life to God and work as a priest when we so desperately need them? Gay men are not animals or sex-crazed fiends (even though some portions of the gay community may give that impression, but so do some portions of the “straight” community). As you said, heterosexual priests have to learn to deal with their own feelings in relation to the women they work with/minister to (who often well outnumber the men in a congregation), and we expect them to. so why should we not have the same expectations of homosexuals–why should we think it would be any harder for them to control themselves? There are undoubtedly men who try and fail, both gay and straight. But it’s a question of self discipline, not sexual orientation. THere is no reason to think a gay man is incapable of having the same level of self discipline as a straight man.
Please note that the editorial staff reserves the right to not post comments it deems to be inappropriate and/or malicious in nature, as well as edit comments for length, clarity and fairness.